LAKE SUPERIOR SOUTH SHORE LISTING | CORNUCOPIA, WISCONSIN

Best Kept Secret

A turn-key income-producing cabin in the heart of Cornucopia, pairing Northwoods character with modern comfort and a proven short-term rental history buyers can model before they tour.

BUYER CALCULATOR

Run the buyer calculator

FULL MLS LISTING

View MLS listing

Best Kept Secret cabin exterior at 22720 Maple Street in Cornucopia

List Price

$344.9K

Bedrooms / Baths

2 / 1

Finished Sq Ft

888

Rental Ready

Furnished

TURN-KEY CORNUCOPIA CABIN

A newer-construction cabin with real rental momentum

Tucked into a quiet pocket of Cornucopia yet just blocks from the beach, marina, shops, and restaurants, this 2-bedroom, 1-bath cabin is built for easy South Shore stays. The log-sided exterior and warm wood interior give it a true Northwoods feel, while central heat and air, high-speed internet, laundry, dishwasher, gas range, and thoughtful furnishings make it comfortable for repeat guests and owners alike.

The cabin is offered furnished and equipped, with a wrap-around deck, gas grill, fire pit, two-car garage, and an established rental operation a buyer can step into or adapt as a private getaway.

Aerial view of Best Kept Secret and its wooded Cornucopia setting

Northwoods comfort, minutes from the water

Aerial view of the Maple Street cabin and lot

Open living dining and kitchen area inside Best Kept Secret

Warm wood living room interior at Best Kept Secret

The cabin

Two queen bedrooms, one full bath with tub, open-concept living, dining, and kitchen space, stainless appliances, full-size laundry, central heat and air, high-speed internet, built-in USB outlets, and comfortable furnishings included.

The location

Set in a quiet pocket of Cornucopia, the cabin is blocks from Siskiwit Bay beach, the marina, shops, and restaurants, with Lost Creek Falls, Siskiwit Falls, and South Shore trails close enough to shape an easy guest itinerary.

RENTAL-INFORMED OWNERSHIP

Run the numbers before you tour

Best Kept Secret has an established short-term rental history with strong repeat guest demand. Use the buyer calculator below to test purchase price, down payment, interest rate, management, and personal-use assumptions against the property's income profile.

2025 Gross Booking Revenue

$52,535

2025 Booked Nights

221

Self-Managed NOI Model

$35,678

INTERACTIVE BUYER CALCULATOR

Explore your ownership picture below

Adjust the purchase price, down payment, interest rate, management fee, personal-use nights, and operating assumptions to see how the cabin's rental performance could offset ownership costs.

Best Kept Secret buyer calculator will load here.

Illustrative financial analysis only. Best Kept Secret figures use historical rental performance where noted. Self-managed and professionally managed scenarios depend on buyer-selected assumptions. Historical performance and projections do not guarantee future revenue, occupancy, expenses, financing terms, licensing, tax treatment, or availability for personal use. Buyers should independently verify all financial information and consult appropriate lending, tax, insurance, legal, and financial professionals. Listing agent is also the seller's property manager.

Best Kept Secret Owner Cost Calculator

1. Tell us how you'd own it

Update the below fields based on your assumptions on purchase price, loan details, etc.

Purchase Price

Down Payment %

Interest Rate %

Loan Term

Management Fee %

Personal Use Nights

Advanced Assumptions

Historical Property Constants

Historical ADR and Mortgage Calculations

Monthly Mortgage P&I

Annual Debt Service

Personal Use Revenue Impact

Projected Gross Rental Revenue

Operating Scenario Calculations

NOI Available Towards Financing

Buyer-Facing Metrics

Owner Cost Coverage %

Potential Annual Surplus

/year before insurance

2. Your Estimated Ownership Picture

MONTHLY MORTGAGE P&I

OWNERSHIP COSTS COVERED

% of modeled annual ownership costs

ESTIMATED OWNER CONTRIBUTION

$/month

WHAT THAT MEANS

PERSONAL USE MODELED

nights/year

Approximate Owner-Use Nights at Break-Even

Approximate Break-Even Personal Use

nights/year

#frm_field_76_container,#frm_form_2_container #frm_field_77_container,#frm_form_2_container #frm_field_78_container,#frm_form_2_container #frm_field_94_container{display:none!important}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .buyer-calc-card,#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .buyer-calc-secondary-result{background:#fff;border:1px solid #d9e2ea;border-radius:8px;padding:18px;box-shadow:0 8px 22px rgba(15,23,42,.08)}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .buyer-calc-highlight{border-color:#2f6f73;background:#f2fbf8}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_74_container{border-left:4px solid #2f6f73;background:#f7fafc;padding:20px 22px;border-radius:8px;color:#10212b}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_74_container h3{grid-column:1/-1;margin-bottom:8px;color:#10212b}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .bmp-what-means-copy{grid-column:1/-1;margin:0 0 16px;color:#10212b;font-size:16px;line-height:1.55}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .buyer-calc-lead{background:#10212b;color:#fff;padding:24px;border-radius:8px}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .buyer-calc-lead h3,#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .buyer-calc-lead label{color:#fff}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container,#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container h3,#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container .frm_primary_label,#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container label,#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container .frm_description,#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container p{color:#fff!important}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container input,#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container textarea,#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container select{background:#fff!important;color:#10212b!important;border-color:#d9e2ea!important}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container input::placeholder,#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style #frm_field_81_container textarea::placeholder{color:#667085!important}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .buyer-calc-lead-field.frm_inside_container{padding-top:0!important}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .buyer-calc-lead-field.frm_inside_container .frm_primary_label{position:static!important;display:block!important;width:auto!important;height:auto!important;padding:0 0 5px!important;margin:0!important;color:#fff!important;font-size:15px!important;line-height:1.35!important;background:transparent!important;transform:none!important}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .buyer-calc-lead-field.frm_inside_container input{margin-top:0!important}
#frm_form_2_container.with_frm_style .buyer-calc-disclosure{font-size:12px;line-height:1.45;color:#6b7280}

3. Want the full numbers?

First name

Phone

Illustrative financial analysis only. Calculations are based on historical 2025 rental performance and the assumptions entered above. Historical performance does not guarantee future rental revenue, occupancy, expenses, financing terms, or availability for personal use. Mortgage estimates include principal and interest only unless otherwise stated. Buyers should independently verify all financial information and consult appropriate lending, tax, insurance, and financial professionals.

If you are human, leave this field blank.